20th Season | 1939-40

Our Town 

Susan and God 

A Slight Case of Murder 

Rain from Heaven 

Private Lives 

Arms and the Man 

Summer Show 

  • The Drunkard or the Fallen Saved 

Workshop Production 

  • The Infernal Machine 

Children's Theatre 

  • The Perils of Perlino 
  • The Reluctant Dragon 
  • Alice in Wonderland 

21st Season | 1940-41 

Dinner at Eight 

Margin for Error 

What a Life 

Death Takes a Holiday 

Knickerbocker Holiday 

The Late Christopher Bean 

Kiss the Boys Goodbye 

Summer Show 

  • Denver Dan's Devilish Deed or Little Nell Has Went Away 

22nd Season | 1941-42

Mr. and Mrs. North 

The Male Animal 

Out of the Frying Pan 

Wingless Victory 

George Washington Slept Here

Flight to the West 

Hay Fever 

Summer Show 
  • Penelope Pureheart or The Seamstress' Secret

Workshop Production 

  • Fly Away Home 

23rd Season | 1942-43

On Borrowed Time 

The Guardsman 

Old Acquaintance 

Ladies in Retirement

Spring Again 

Arsenic and Old Lace 

Summer Show 

  • The Drunkard or the Fallen Saved 

24th Season | 1943-44

You Can't Take It With You 

Love from a Stranger 

The Philadelphia Story 

The Barker 

Claudia 

The Torch Bearers 

25th Season | 1944-45 

Skylark 

Junior Miss

Double Door

Meet the Prince 

Wedding Bells 

Over 21

26th Season | 1945-46

Blithe Spirit 

The Hasty Heart

Ramshackle Inn 

The Circle 

Mrs. Gertrude Lennox 

The Soldier's Wife 

27th Season | 1946-47 

Kiss and Tell 

Angel Street

Petticoat Feve 

Guest in the House

 Ten Little Indians 

My Sister Eileen 

Experimental Laboratory 
  • The Emperor Jones 
  • Nothing but the Truth 

28th Season | 1947-48

Years Ago 

Joan of Lorraine 

Laura 

Foolish Notion 

You Touched Me 

John Loves Mary 

Experimental Laboratory 

  • The Yellow Jacket 

29th Season | 1948-49

Our Hearts Were Young and Gay 

Antigone 

Libel 

The Women 

The Winslow Boy 

Heaven Can Wait 

Christmas Production
  • Cricket on The Hearth 

Experimental Laboratory 

  • Androcles and the Lion