20th Season | 1939-40
Our Town
Susan and God
A Slight Case of Murder
Rain from Heaven
Private Lives
Arms and the Man
Summer Show
- The Drunkard or the Fallen Saved
Workshop Production
Children's Theatre
- The Perils of Perlino
- The Reluctant Dragon
- Alice in Wonderland
21st Season | 1940-41
Dinner at Eight
Margin for Error
What a Life
Death Takes a Holiday
Knickerbocker Holiday
The Late Christopher Bean
Kiss the Boys Goodbye
Summer Show
- Denver Dan's Devilish Deed or Little Nell Has Went Away
22nd Season | 1941-42
Mr. and Mrs. North
The Male Animal
Out of the Frying Pan
Wingless Victory
George Washington Slept Here
Flight to the West
Hay Fever
Summer Show
- Penelope Pureheart or The Seamstress' Secret
Workshop Production
23rd Season | 1942-43
On Borrowed Time
The Guardsman
Old Acquaintance
Ladies in Retirement
Spring Again
Arsenic and Old Lace
Summer Show
- The Drunkard or the Fallen Saved
24th Season | 1943-44
You Can't Take It With You
Love from a Stranger
The Philadelphia Story
The Barker
Claudia
The Torch Bearers
25th Season | 1944-45
Skylark
Junior Miss
Double Door
Meet the Prince
Wedding Bells
Over 21
26th Season | 1945-46
Blithe Spirit
The Hasty Heart
Ramshackle Inn
The Circle
Mrs. Gertrude Lennox
The Soldier's Wife
27th Season | 1946-47
Kiss and Tell
Angel Street
Petticoat Feve
Guest in the House
Ten Little Indians
My Sister Eileen
Experimental Laboratory
- The Emperor Jones
- Nothing but the Truth
28th Season | 1947-48
Years Ago
Joan of Lorraine
Laura
Foolish Notion
You Touched Me
John Loves Mary
Experimental Laboratory
29th Season | 1948-49
Our Hearts Were Young and Gay
Antigone
Libel
The Women
The Winslow Boy
Heaven Can Wait
Christmas Production
Experimental Laboratory