91st Season | 2010-11
- Annie Get Your Gun
- Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure
- A Christmas Carol
- Amadeus
- Cabaret
- Picnic
- Crazy For You
Next Stage
- A Delicate Balance
- [Title of Show]
- Richard III
92nd Season | 2011-12
- Bye Bye Birdie
- Emma
- A Christmas Carol
- The Importance Of Being Earnest
- Chicago
- Noises Off
- No, No, Nanette
Next Stage
- Glengarry Glen Ross
- A Celebration of Sondheim: Concert
- Circle Mirror Transformation
- Hedda Gabler
93rd Season | 2012-13
- Fiddler On The Roof
- Dangerous Liaisons
- A Christmas Carol
- Six Degrees Of Separation
- A Chorus Line
- Brighton Beach Memoirs
- Singin' In The Rain
Next Stage
- Talley's Folly
- Altar Boyz
- A Steady Rain
- Sylvia
94th Season | 2013-14
- The Royal Family
- Young Frankenstein
- A Christmas Carol
- Death of a Salesman
- Jesus Christ Superstar
- Harvey
- The Music Man
Next Stage
- Proof
- The Musicals of Musicals (The Musical!)
- As You Like It
- The Submission
95th Season | 2014-15
- The Addams Family- The Musical
- The Heiress
- A Christmas Carol
- Of Mice And Men
- The Boy From Oz
- The Philadelphia Story
- Anything Goes
Next Stage
- The Member Of The Wedding
- Tintypes
- Copenhagen
- Rapture, Blister, Burn
96th Season | 2015-16
- The Producers
- Wait Until Dark
- A Christmas Carol
- The Lion In Winter
- Into The Woods
- Hay Fever
- Oliver!
Next Stage
- The Gin Game
- Doubt
- Mothers And Sons
- The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)
Summer Showcase Performance
97th Season | 2016-17
- Beauty and the Beast
- The City of Conversation
- A Christmas Carol
- 39 Steps
- Side Show
- Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
- South Pacific
Next Stage
- Liberace!
- One Ham Manlet
- Sense and Sensibility
- Rasheeda Speaking
Summer Showcase Performance
- Debbie Sings: Judy, Just for You
98th Season | 2017-18
- Shrek The Musical
- Stage Kiss
- A Christmas Carol
- Fences
- The Drowsy Chaperone
- August: Osage County
- 42nd Street
Next Stage
- 12 Angry Jurors
- Falsettos
- Souvenir
- An Act of God
99th Season | 2018-19
- Disney Newsies
- Dracula
- A Christmas Carol
- To Kill a Mockingbird
- 1776
- The Man Who Came to Dinner
- Hairspray
Next Stage
- Heisenberg
- The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
- Little Women
- The Clean House